Skip to main content

Table 4 End-products produced by the N. frontalis + M. gottschalkii co-culture YakQH5 and the N. frontalis YakQH5 fungus grown on the 5 substrates

From: Roughage biodegradation by natural co-cultures of rumen fungi and methanogens from Qinghai yaks

End-products

Wheat straw

Corn stalk

Rice straw

Oat straw

Sorghum straw

N. frontalis + M. gottschalkii Co-culture YakQH5

CH4 (mmol/g DM)

Day2

1.5 a

1.0 b

1.7 a

0.9 b

1.2 b

Day3

2.8 a

2.6 a

3.0 a

2.1 b

2.3 b

Day4

3.8 a

3.9 a

3.5 a

2.5 b

2.9 b

Day5

4.6 a

4.2 a

3.9 ab

4.0 ab

3.0 b

Average

3.2 a

2.9 a

3.0 a

2.4 b

2.4 b

Acetate (mmol/g DM)

     

Day2

2.0 b

1.9 c

2.1 b

2.2 b

2.9 a

Day3

4.0 b

4.0 ab

4.6 a

3.7 b

5.0 a

Day4

6.2 b

6.0 b

7.1 a

5.9 c

6.5 b

Day5

8.0 b

7.3 c

8.6 a

7.3 c

8.2 b

Average

5.1 b

4.8 c

5.6 a

4.8 c

5.7 a

N. frontalis YakQH5 Fungus

H2 (mmol/g DM)

Day2

0.5 a

0.2 b

0.4 a

0.2 b

0.5 a

Day3

1.8 b

1.0 d

1.5 c

2.0 a

1.7 b

Day4

2.8 a

2.1 c

1.9 d

2.7 a

2.5 b

Day5

3.9 a

2.5 c

2.4 c

3.0 b

2.8 b

Average

2.0

1.5

1.6

2.0

1.8

Formate (mmol/g DM)

     

Day2

0.4 b

0.4 b

0.6 a

0.3 c

0.6 a

Day3

1.1 b

1.1 b

1.2 a

1.1 b

1.3 a

Day4

1.7 b

1.6 b

1.6 b

1.6 b

1.9 a

Day5

1.9 c

2.0 b

2.1b

1.9 c

2.5 a

Average

1.3 c

1.3 c

1.4 b

1.2 d

1.6 a

Acetate (mmol/g DM)

Day2

1.5 a

1.0 c

1.5 a

1.3 b

1.2 b

Day3

2.8 a

1.9 c

2.7 a

2.0 b

2.1 b

Day4

4.0 a

3.3 b

4.1 a

3.1 b

3.2 b

Day5

5.3 a

4.1 c

5.5 a

4.4 b

4.6 b

Average

3.4 a

2.6 b

3.5 a

2.7 b

2.8 b

Lactate (mmol/g DM)

     

Day2

0.6 c

0.8 a

0.5 d

0.5 d

0.7 b

Day3

1.3 b

1.5 a

1.2 b

1.2 b

1.2 b

Day4

1.9 b

2.4 a

1.8 b

1.6 c

1.7 c

Day5

2.1 b

2.4 a

1.9 c

1.9 c

2.5 a

Average

1.5 b

1.8 a

1.4 c

1.3 c

1.5 b

Ethanol (mmol/g DM)

     

Day2

10.5 a

8.0 b

6.3 c

9.5 b

7.0 c

Day3

30.3 a

23.7 b

19.1 c

29.7 a

25.0 b

Day4

Day5

Average

37.1 a

45.8 a

30.9 a

30.3 b

35.0 c

24.3 c

24.7 c

27.9 d

19.5 d

34.6 a

39.9 b

28.4 b

30.1 b

33.4 c

23.9 c

  1. Day2-Day5: along the 5-day incubation; a, b, c, d indicate statistical difference (p < 0.05)