Skip to main content

Table 2 Neutral detergent fiber and acid detergent fiber of alfalfa under different treatments (%)

From: Response of alfalfa growth to arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi and phosphate-solubilizing bacteria under different phosphorus application levels

Treatments

NDF (%)

ADF (%)

First cut

Second cut

First cut

Second cut

J0P0

54.49 ± 0.87Bc

48.62 ± 0.42Ac

41.98 ± 0.84Cc

37.97 ± 0.34Ac

J0P1

58.83 ± 0.40Aa

51.05 ± 0.57Bb

46.82 ± 0.44Ab

39.45 ± 0.49Ab

J0P2

57.47 ± 0.46Cb

46.89 ± 0.04Bd

48.49 ± 0.48Aa

41.76 ± 0.23Aa

J0P3

57.36 ± 0.45Ab

54.98 ± 0.79Aa

46.10 ± 0.33Ab

41.01 ± 0.44Aa

J1P0

54.09 ± 0.58Bc

45.89 ± 0.65Bc

45.57 ± 0.54Ab

36.67 ± 0.37Bb

J1P1

54.61 ± 0.20Cc

52.40 ± 0.30Aa

45.70 ± 0.87Bb

38.88 ± 0.40Aa

J1P2

59.54 ± 0.46Ba

50.98 ± 0.16Ab

47.43 ± 0.66Ba

38.58 ± 0.43Ba

J1P3

55.60 ± 0.47Bb

45.80 ± 0.29Bc

46.73 ± 0.82Aa

35.70 ± 0.61Cc

J2P0

51.20 ± 0.49Cc

45.75 ± 0.96Bc

42.01 ± 0.66Cb

38.30 ± 0.79Aa

J2P1

56.76 ± 0.67Ba

49.45 ± 0.28Ca

42.63 ± 0.63Cab

37.94 ± 0.20Ba

J2P2

54.34 ± 0.34Dd

47.81 ± 0.47Bb

43.56 ± 0.49 Da

38.49 ± 0.72Ba

J2P3

54.41 ± 0.37Cb

45.25 ± 0.68Bc

41.89 ± 0.47Bb

36.19 ± 0.31Cb

J3P0

57.98 ± 0.20Ac

42.48 ± 0.54Cc

44.54 ± 0.46Bb

35.89 ± 0.23Bc

J3P1

59.09 ± 0.29Ab

49.38 ± 0.10Ca

46.10 ± 0.17ABa

39.65 ± 0.63Aa

J3P2

61.71 ± 0.55Aa

43.97 ± 0.65Cb

46.06 ± 0.28Ca

36.45 ± 0.89Cbc

J3P3

53.98 ± 0.30Cd

43.63 ± 0.69Cb

41.81 ± 0.76Bc

37.11 ± 0.72Bb

J

**

**

**

**

P

**

**

**

**

J × P

**

**

**

**

  1. Different capital letters in the same column indicated significant difference in different bacteria treatments under the same phosphorus application conditions (P < 0.05), differences small letters in the same column mean significant difference under the same bacteria application conditions (P < 0.05). ** indicates significant difference extremely (P < 0.01)
  2. P0, P1, P2, and P3 represent 0 mg kg−1, 50 mg kg−1, 100 mg kg−1, and 150 mg P kg−1, respectively. J0, J1, J2, and J3 represent CK, Fm, Bm, and Fm × Bm, respectively