Skip to main content

Table 2 End-products produced by the (Piromyces + M. ruminantium) Yak-G18 co-culture grown on chopped wheat straw, corn stalk, rice straw, Chinese wildrye and medicago sativa during the 7 days’ incubation

From: Characterization of natural co-cultures of Piromyces with Methanobrevibacter ruminantium from yaks grazing on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau: a microbial consortium with high potential in plant biomass degradation

End-products

(Piromyces + M. ruminantium) Yak-G18 co-culture

2 days

3 days

4 days

5 days

6 days

7 days

Average

Acetate (mM)

 ws

9.23d

12.36c

20.56b

23.10b

24.13d

23.36c

18.79a

 cs

15.16ab

22.24ab

29.27a

31.04a

37.07ab

39.60a

29.07ab

 rs

11.34cd

15.41bc

20.34b

24.55b

30.23c

32.01b

22.31c

 cw

16.83a

23.24a

29.94a

32.37a

38.41a

41.27a

30.34a

 ms

13.50bc

21.57b

28.61a

30.37a

33.74bc

36.94ab

27.45b

CH4 (mmol/g DM)

 ws

0.52b

0.86a

1.27a

1.44ab

2.33a

2.35a

1.46a

 cs

0.74a

0.86a

1.31a

1.55a

1.86ab

1.90b

1.37b

 rs

0.60ab

0.96a

1.16a

0.93c

1.42bc

1.62bc

1.11c

 cw

0.78a

0.89a

1.44a

1.65a

1.86ab

1.96b

1.43ab

 ms

0.61ab

0.79a

1.14a

1.20bc

1.30c

1.28c

1.05c

d-lactate (mM)

 ws

0.15a

0.19a

0.24a

0.24a

0.24a

0.23a

0.22a

 cs

0.12a

0.15a

0.16b

0.16b

0.16a

0.17ab

0.15b

 rs

0.14a

0.16a

0.19ab

0.21ab

0.21a

0.22a

0.19ab

 cw

0.12a

0.14a

0.13b

0.16b

0.16a

0.15b

0.14b

 ms

0.13a

0.16a

0.17b

0.16b

0.21a

0.21ab

0.17ab

l-lactate (mM)

 ws

3.86a

4.41a

4.98a

5.22ab

5.54a

4.86a

4.81a

 cs

3.92a

4.32ab

5.52a

5.79a

5.76a

4.89a

5.03a

 rs

3.26a

3.26b

3.50b

3.56b

3.29b

3.57a

3.40b

 cw

3.72a

4.19ab

5.42a

5.73a

5.63a

4.79a

4.91a

 ms

3.59a

3.99ab

5.19a

5.46ab

5.10ab

4.55a

4.64a

Lactate (mM)

 ws

4.02a

4.60a

5.21a

5.45ab

5.78a

5.09a

5.03a

 cs

4.04a

4.47a

5.68a

5.93a

5.93a

5.06a

5.19a

 rs

3.40a

3.42a

3.69b

3.77b

3.49b

3.80a

3.59b

 cw

3.84a

4.32a

5.55a

6.01a

5.79a

4.94a

5.05a

 ms

3.72a

4.14a

5.36a

5.62ab

5.31ab

4.76a

4.82ab

Succinate (mM)

 ws

0.02a

0.04ab

0.05a

0.05a

0.06ab

0.06ab

0.05a

 cs

0.03a

0.04ab

0.05a

0.06a

0.07a

0.08a

0.05a

 rs

0.03a

0.03b

0.04a

0.05a

0.05b

0.05b

0.04a

 cw

0.04a

0.05a

0.06a

0.06a

0.08a

0.08a

0.06a

 ms

0.03a

0.03b

0.05a

0.07a

0.08a

0.08a

0.06a

  1. Means in a row without same superscript letter differ as noted p value
  2. SEM standard error of means (n = 3), ws wheat straw, cs corn stalk, rs rice straw, cw Chinese wildrye, ms medicago sativa