- Original article
- Open Access
The synergistic effect of Selenium (selenite, –SeO3 2−) dose and irradiance intensity in Chlorella cultures
AMB Express volume 7, Article number: 56 (2017)
Microalgae are able to metabolize inorganic selenium (Se) to organic forms (e.g. Se-proteins); nevertheless at certain Se concentration culture growth is inhibited. The aim of this work was to confirm the hypothesis that the limit of Se tolerance in Chlorella cultures is related to photosynthetic performance, i.e. depends on light intensity. We studied the relation between the dose and irradiance to find the range of Se tolerance in laboratory and outdoor cultures. At low irradiance (250 µmol photons m−2 s−1), the daily dose of Se below 8.5 mg per g of biomass (<20 µM) partially stimulated the photosynthetic activity (relative electron transport rate) and growth of Chlorella cultures (biomass density of ~1.5 g DW L−1) compared to the control (no Se added). It was accompanied by substantial Se incorporation to microalgae biomass (~0.5 mg Se g−1 DW). When the Se daily dose and level of irradiance were doubled (16 mg Se g−1 DW; 500 µmol photons m−2 s−1), the photosynthetic activity and growth were stimulated for several days and ample incorporation of Se to biomass (7.1 mg g−1 DW) was observed. Yet, the same Se daily dose under increased irradiance (750 µmol photons m−2 s−1) caused the synergistic effect manifested by significant inhibition of photosynthesis, growth and lowered Se incorporation to biomass. In the present experiments Chl fluorescence techniques were used to monitor photosynthetic activity for determination of optimal Se doses in order to achieve efficient incorporation without substantial inhibition of microalgae growth when producing Se-enriched biomass.
Selenium (Se) is a natural trace element that may alternate from an essential micro-nutrient to a toxic compound within a narrow concentration level. Microalgae are able to metabolize inorganic selenium (Se) salts to organic forms as a part of detoxification process, but at certain concentration culture growth becomes inhibited. At nanomolar concentrations Se salts can be beneficial for growth of some microalgae (Li et al. 2003), but further up, at micromolar concentrations may result in a decreased growth rate, photosynthesis inhibition and disturbance to the cell ultrastructure (Morlon et al. 2005; Geoffroy et al. 2007; Fournier et al. 2010; Vítová et al. 2011; Gojkovic et al. 2015). Typical Se content in freshwaters is found in the range of 0.1–2 nM (equivalent to 0.08–0.16 μg Se L−1), but much higher concentrations reaching 5 µM (equivalent to 400 µg Se L−1) have been observed in contaminated areas (Conde and Sanz Alaejos 1997; Sun et al. 2014). Both selenite (SeIV, –SeO4 2−) and selenate (SeVI, –SeO3 2−), two major inorganic forms of Se, are toxic to microalgae at higher concentrations (Geoffroy et al. 2007; Morlon et al. 2005) although selenite was found to be more lethal than selenite (Wheeler et al. 1982). These salts are readily incorporated by microalgae, though selenate is accumulated about ten times more efficiently than selenate due to different membrane transporters (Vriens et al. 2016). For nutritional purposes, Se is often supplied in the form of inorganic salts (selenite, selenate), but organically bound selenium in microalgae biomass (Se-proteins) is more beneficial and less toxic to humans and animals and can be used as food and feed supplement (Becker 2007; Doucha et al. 2009; Gojkovic et al. 2015; Kouba et al. 2014; Novoselov et al. 2002).
Microalgae play a crucial role in Se-metabolism due the uptake and biotransformation, and the subsequent transfer upwards into the food chain. Basically, three mechanisms are associated with Se removal by microalgae: (i) biosorption of Se ions on the cell surface, (ii) intracellular uptake of Se ions, and (iii) chemical transformation of Se ions (Neumann et al. 2003; Pardo et al. 2003; Pelah and Ephraim 2005; Oh et al. 2009; Umysová et al. 2009; Gojkovic et al. 2014, 2015). The effects of Se, and its metabolism and bioaccumulation have recently been studied in various groups of microalgae including Spirulina (Li et al. 2003; Mane et al. 2013; Pronina et al. 2002), Scenedesmus (Umysová et al. 2009), Chlorella (Sun et al. 2014; Gojkovic et al. 2014) or Chlamydomonas (Geoffroy et al. 2007; Morlon et al. 2005). At low concentration levels, up to 10 mg Se L−1, i.e. ~12 µM, cell growth and functioning are not inhibited (Umysová et al. 2009) and microalgae are able to incorporate and transform Se salts to bioavailable organic compounds—proteins containing selenated amino acids, replacing sulphur in methionine and cysteine (for review see ref. Araie and Shiraiwa 2016). Some species also metabolize Se to volatile compounds—dimethylselenide, dimethyldiselenide and dimethylselenenylsulfide (Fan et al. 1997; Larsen et al. 2001; Neumann et al. 2003; Guadayol et al. 2016). Adverse effects of Se on microalgal cultures are usually observed as decrease of population densities and/or growth rates, in proportion to Se concentration in the culture medium. Toxicity to microalgae culture is usually reflected as the corresponding EC50 value. For example, the EC50 values for selenite were found 80 μM in Chlamydomonas cultures (Morlon et al. 2005), and 418 μM in Scenedesmus (Vítová et al. 2011). At higher doses (above tens of micromoles), Se accumulation may result in inhibited photosynthesis, decreased growth rate, and changes of the cell ultrastructure (Geoffroy et al. 2007; Morlon et al. 2005; Vítová et al. 2011). The uptake of Se in excess to requirements may cause metabolic reactions, possibly some photo-oxidative damage (Chen et al. 2005) that can eventually lead to cell death (Schiavon et al. 2012; Sun et al. 2014).
Fast and sensitive monitoring techniques are employed to detect early stress effects in microalgae cultures. These can be promptly assessed as changes of the photosystem II (PSII) photochemical performance that is reliably determined by chlorophyll (Chl) fluorescence, a sensitive and easy-to-use technique. Recently, we have used fast fluorescence induction kinetics and rapid light-response curves of electron transport activity for detection of various stressors in microalgae cultures (Masojídek et al. 2011a; Malapascua et al. 2014). These techniques reflect the absorption, distribution and utilization efficiency of energy by cells and can indicate Se effect on photosynthetic activity in microalgae cultures (e.g. Geoffroy et al. 2007; Gojkovic et al. 2015).
In this work, we aimed to study the synergistic effect of Se (selenite, SeO3 2−) doses and irradiance intensity on Chlorella vulgaris cultures. Changes of photosynthetic performance (measured as Chl fluorescence variables) were investigated in detail in correlation with growth, pigment composition and Se incorporation to biomass. Here, photosynthesis measurements were used in order to control microalgae activity during Se treatment and incorporation. The experiments at various irradiance intensities showed that the rate and extent of Se uptake depends on photosynthetic performance of the culture. In this way suitable doses of Se can be estimated for mass cultivation to produce a bulk of Se-enriched biomass for nutritional purposes.
Materials and methods
The fast-growing microalga Chlorella vulgaris, strain R117 (CCALA 10258, Culture Collection of Autotrophic Organisms, Institute of Botany, Třeboň, Czech Republic) was cultivated in a modified inorganic medium (Šetlík et al. 1972; Zachleder and Šetlík 1982), containing the following compounds (in mg L−1): KNO3, 2021; KH2PO4, 340; MgSO4·7H2O, 989; ferric-sodium chelatonate, 18.4; CaCl2, 16; H3BO3, 1.9; MnCl2·4H2O, 7.3; ZnSO4·7H2O, 7; CuSO4·5H2O, 2; CoSO4·7H2O, 1.4; (NH4)6Mo7O24, 0.08; and NH4VO3, 0.06, pH 7.4.
The cultures were grown in glass columns (working volume 330 mL; internal diameter 35 mm) that were submerged in temperature-controlled water bath (28–29 °C) and mixed by bubbling with air +1.5% CO2 (v/v) (Fig. 1). The batch cultures were exposed to continuous illumination between for 4 days. Photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) provided by a horizontal panel of high frequency cool fluorescent tubes (36 W/830 Lumilux, Osram, Germany) was measured directly inside an empty cultivation column to adjust light intensity using a quantum sensor (LI-190SA, cosine-corrected up to 80° angle of incidence) coupled to a light meter (LI-250, Li-Cor, USA).
Outdoor pilot experiment was carried out under ambient irradiance light in thin-layer cascades (area of 220 m2 with total cultivation volume of 2200 L) for 7 days in June 2015. More detailed description of the outdoor units and cultivation regime is shown elsewhere (Masojídek et al. 2011b).
Growth and selenium treatments
Optical density (OD750) of the culture was measured at 750 nm using a spectrophotometer as it is approximately linearly related to biomass density (DW). Samples of microalgae cultures were diluted accordingly prior to measurement to keep the absorbance in a linear range. Biomass density was assayed as dry weight (DW) by filtering 5 mL of culture samples on pre-weighed fiberglass filters (GC-50). Then, these were dried in an oven at 105 °C for 3 h, transferred to a desiccator to equilibrate to laboratory temperature and weighed. In all laboratory experiments, well-growing cultures of Chlorella were suspended in the fresh medium to the initial biomass density of about 1.5 g/L.
The robust strain R117 of Chlorella was selected as model microalga in this work as in preliminary trials it showed tolerance to high doses of selenite (not shown here). In order to select appropriate Se dose in our experiments we have considered the tested concentration range of Se salts in cultivation media that was usually between 0.1 and 80 mg L−1 (1–500 μM) (e.g. Bennett 1988; Morlon et al. 2005; Geoffroy et al. 2007; Umysová et al. 2009; Fournier et al. 2010; Gojkovic et al. 2014, 2015).
In one series of experiments, Se was added as a stock solution of sodium selenite (Na2SeO3) once a day to each cultivation column (250 µmol photons m−2 s−1) at various concentration (2.5, 8.5 and 25 mg Se per g of starting biomass density; representing final concentrations of about 19, 65 and 190 µmol L−1, respectively) to determine effective concentration. In the other series of experiments, various light intensities (250, 500 and 750 µmol photons m−2 s−1, respectively) were used to study the irradiance-dependent effect of Se treatment (16 mg Se g−1 biomass added twice a day as Na2SeO3; final concentration of about 122 µmol L−1). All Se treatments were performed in duplicates. Control cultures were grown in the absence of Se. Distilled water was added to columns before each sampling to compensate volume lost by evaporation.
In outdoor trial Se was added to Chlorella cultures in the cascade units in the form of Na2SeO3 twice a day (at 8 a.m. and 1 p.m.) to keep its concentration of about 20 µmol L−1.
Analysis of selenium content
For Se analysis culture samples (50 mL) were centrifuged and sediments of cells were freeze-dried before analysis. Biomass was mineralized in the microwave decomposition equipment (Milestone 1200 Mega) using nitric acid and hydrogen peroxide. The total amount of Se in biomass was determined using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS, Agilent 7700×) by a commercial company (Healthcare Institute Ltd., Ústí nad Labem, Czech Republic).
Chlorophyll fluorescence measurements
For Chl fluorescence measurements, samples were taken from the cultures and measured in triplicates (data presented as mean ± SE) at specified daytimes. Before measurement, the cultures were diluted to 0.2–0.3 g DW L−1 (corresponding to 5–7 mg Chl L−1) with distilled water, dark adapted for 5–10 min and then transferred to a measuring chamber. In this way, we prevented re-absorption problems in a dense culture and provided sufficient illumination in the dark-acclimated samples (with an oxidized plastoquinone pool). Measurements were carried out under well-defined laboratory conditions and ‘light’ exposure history to avoid modifying the photo acclimation state of the cells.
Two Chl fluorescence techniques were used for culture monitoring. While rapid fluorescence induction kinetics provides information on the reduction of the photosynthetic electron transport chain, fluorescence quenching analysis gives information on the balance between photosynthetic electron transport and Calvin-Benson cycle (Malapascua et al. 2014). The fluorescence nomenclature in this paper follows Schreiber et al. (1986) as later elaborated by Kooten and Snel (1990) and Kromkamp and Foster (2003).
Rapid light-response curves
Rapid light-response curves (RLCs) of microalgae samples were measured using a pulse-amplitude-modulation fluorometer (PAM-2500, H. Walz, Germany) in a light-protected measuring chamber with mixing (3 mL glass cuvette, light path of 10 mm). A series of stepwise increasing irradiance intensities (red LEDs; 0-2000 μmol photons m−2 s−1) were applied in 20 s intervals to obtain the ‘steady-state’ fluorescence level (F′) and then a saturating pulse (>10,000 μmol photons m−2 s−1, 0.6 s duration) was triggered to reach the maximum fluorescence level (Fm′). At each irradiance intensity, the actual (or effective) photosystem II (PSII) photochemical quantum yield in the light-adapted state, designated as YII was calculated as (Fm′–F′)/Fm′; it represents actual operational ability of photosynthesizing cells to convert light power into chemical energy. The so called relative electron transport rate through PSII, rETR (dimensionless) was calculated as multiplication of YII by the photosynthetically active radiation EPAR, rETR = YII × EPAR and plotted against EPAR (e.g. Hofstraat et al. 1994; Ralph and Gademann 2005; White et al. 2011). RLCs for ETR were constructed and analyzed to determine important variables. In order to estimate maximum value, rETRmax, and the value of irradiance saturating photosynthesis, or onset of light saturation (Ek), the rETR vs. irradiance curves were fitted to the non-linear least-squares regression model by Eilers and Peeters (1988) (PAM Win–3 Software provided by H. Walz), The minimum and maximum fluorescence levels (Fo, Fm) were determined using a weak modulated light (<0.15 μmol photons m−2 s−1, frequency of 0.5–1 kHz) in the dark adapted samples (1st step of RLC; actinic irradiance = 0). The maximum PSII quantum yield was calculated as the ratio of variable to maximum fluorescence, Fv/Fm = (Fm–Fo)/Fm.
Fast fluorescence induction kinetics (OJIP-test)
A hand-held fluorometer (AquaPen AP-100, produced by P.S.I. Ltd, Brno, Czech Republic) adapted for liquid samples was used to follow rapid fluorescence induction kinetics (~1 s) in microalgae cultures. Dark-adapted samples (5–10 min) were applied to a 3 mL measuring cuvette (light path of 10 mm) that was mounted in a light-protected holder in front of the detector (adjustable measuring light pulses, ~2.5 µs) while illuminating red LEDs served as high-intensity continuous light source from both sides of the cuvette (up to 3000 µmol photon m−2 s−1), perpendicular to the fluorescence detector. The fast fluorescence induction kinetics was measured in the time range between 50 µs to 1 s; it started upon illumination (saturating continuous light) of dark-adapted microalgae culture as the signal rises rapidly from the origin (O) to a peak (P) via two infections—J (Vj) and I (Vi) (Strasser and Srivastava 1995; Goltsev et al. 2016). The O point of the fluorescence induction curve is a minimum value (designated as constant fluorescence yield Fo at 50 µs) when plastoquinone (PQ) electron acceptors (QA and QB) of the PSII complex are fully oxidized. It represents the signal emitted from excited Chl-a molecules in the light-harvesting complex II before excitons have migrated to the PSII reaction center. The inflection J occurs after ~2–3 ms of illumination and reflects the dynamic equilibrium (quasi-steady state) between the QA reduction and its oxidation. The J–I phase (at 30–50 ms) is due to the closure of the remaining centers (further reduction of QA and various redox states of temporary maximum of Q A − Q B 2− ) and the I–P phase (ends at about 300–500 ms) corresponds to the full reduction of the plastoquinone pool (equivalent to maximum fluorescence level Fm).
Chlorophyll and total carotenoid contents were determined in 80% acetone by breaking microalgae cells by intensive abrasion with sea sand for 2 min using a vortex mixer. The supernatant containing pigments was collected after centrifugation. The extraction was repeated several times until the pellet was clear of pigments. The absorbance of the combined supernatants of all extraction steps was measured using a high resolution spectrophotometer with a slit width of 0.5 nm (UV 2600 UV–VIS, Shimadzu, Japan) and the concentrations of pigments were calculated according to Wellburn (1994).
Sigma Plot 11.0 was used to determine significant differences between treatments. One-way ANOVA and Post-Hoc test was conducted for comparison of Se treatment to control cultures. P values lower than 0.05 were considered to be significantly different. Statistical analysis was only done for pigment contents and Se accumulation in microalgae biomass.
In one series of laboratory experiments (Trial 1), various concentrations of Se (2.5, 8.5, 25 and 85 mg g−1 DW) were applied to Chlorella cultures under low irradiance of 250 µmol photons m−2 s−1 to determine effective Se dose that inhibits photosynthesis and subsequently growth and correlate these variables with Se uptake. In the other series of laboratory experiments (Trial 2) the concentration of 16 mg Se g−1 DW was used under various light intensities (250, 500 and 750 µmol photons m−2 s−1) to study the irradiance-dependent rate of Se uptake. The biomass density at the start of both experiments was 1.2–1.6 g DW L−1. Finally, laboratory experimental data were used in outdoor cultivation of Chlorella (Trial 3) to produce a bulk of Se-enriched biomass for nutritional purposes.
Trial 1: changes in Chlorella cultures caused by various Selenium concentrations
In this series of experiments the Chlorella growth and physiology was studied after the addition of various Se concentration (added as selenite) from low and stimulating (2.5 mg g−1 DW) to highly inhibiting concentration (85 mg g−1 DW) and compared to the control cultures (no Se addition). The Se concentration of 2.5 and 8.5 mg Se g−1 DW caused a slight stimulation of growth during 3 day trial. A sigmoidal course was found with an initial slower phase, followed by acceleration of growth and it started to decelerate after 48 h (Fig. 2a). The results showed that in the control culture (no Se added), the biomass concentration increased by about 2.5 times and it reached stationary phase after 72 h. In the cultures treated with 2.5 and 8.5 mg Se g−1 DW, the growth rate was slightly faster. In case of the 25 mg Se g−1 DW, the culture grew up to 48 h and then the biomass density started to decrease. The higher concentration of Se (85 mg Se g−1 DW) caused a strong inhibition of growth and photosynthetic activity (not shown here).
The growth analysis was accompanied by fluorescence measurements of RLCs and OJIP kinetics. Although the growth rate was still similar during first 48 h in the Se treated cultures, we found clear changes in RLCs as compared to the control (Fig. 3). The courses of rETR calculated from RLCs were similar in the control and 2.5 mg Se treated culture, even in the latter there was found slight stimulation after 24 h (Fig. 4). After 48 h, the culture treated with 8.5 mg Se showed about 40% decrease of the rETR activity and the one treated with 25 mg Se g−1 DW dropped to 18% (Fig. 3a). Nevertheless, even in the cultures treated with 2.5 and 8.5 mg Se g−1 DW, the rETR decreased by 22 and 60%, respectively after 72 h, as compared to the control, most probably due to the onset of Se inhibition. Three variables—maximum PSII quantum yield, Fv/Fm, maximum of relative electron transport rate rETRmax and photosynthesis-saturating irradiance Ek were calculated from RLCs (Fig. 4a–c). These variables were affected differently as a function of Se concentration. The Fv/Fm values varied a little between 0.61 and 0.66 on Day 1–3, showing that the cultures were in a good physiological state, slightly increasing from Day 1 to Day 3 by 11–27%; only the Fv/Fm values in the culture containing 25 mg Se g−1 DW decreased by about 40% on Day 3 (Fig. 4a). The values of rETR in the control culture were rather stable during the trial—between 115 and 130. In the cultures treated with 2.5 and 8.5 mg Se g−1 DW, the rETRmax values were stimulated up to about 166–177 for the first 24 h, but not in the culture treated with 25 mg Se as it decreased by 20 and 80% on Day 1 and 2, respectively (Fig. 4b). The variable Ek corresponding to light saturation is used to characterize the photo acclimation status of microalgae cultures (Serodio et al. 2006). These values showed a decreasing trend after 24 h that probably reflects increasing biomass density and culture acclimation to lower irradiance. A significant drop of the Ek values was found only in the cultures treated with 25 mg Se g−1 DW; after 48 h of the trial meaning that this culture was strongly inhibited by Se addition (Fig. 4c).
Rapid fluorescence induction kinetics recorded as OJIP curves in the control and cultures treated with various concentrations of Se indicated inhibitory changes of PSII redox status only at Se concentration of 8.5 and 25 mg Se g−1 DW after 48–72 h, respectively. It was manifested by the increased Vj and Vi values in the cultures starting from Day 2 (Figs. 5a, b, 6a, b) which means that the electron transport through the PSII complex was inhibited due to higher reduction of the electron acceptors QA and QB and the cultures were not able to utilize the energy input for growth.
As concerns Chl content in biomass, it was about 2.2% at the start and the maximum values between 3.4 were reached in these laboratory cultures after 24 h; then these decreased to 2.5–2.8 being relatively stable on Days 2 and 3 (Fig. 7a). Higher Se concentration did not significantly affect the total Chl content in the cultures even if the rETRmax values were significantly decreased (72 h). The content value of carotenoids was about 0.23% at the start and the maximum value of 0.5% were reached during exposure to 8.5 mg g−1 Se after 72 h (data are not shown). This increase in the carotenoids pigments was attributed to the protection provided by carotenoids to chloroplasts against oxidative damage (Schiavon et al. 2012).
As concerns Se accumulation in Chlorella biomass, at low dose (2.5 mg g−1 DW) added to the culture, the content was 101 µg Se g−1 DW after 24 h that was about 50% of that (208 µg Se g−1 DW) found in the culture treated with 8.5 mg g−1 DW (Fig. 8a). In the cultures treated with low and medium dose of Se, its accumulation reflected the partial stimulation of rETRmax (Fig. 8a vs. Fig. 4b). After 72 h the content of Se in biomass was increased to 251 and 281 µg g−1 DW, respectively while about 10 and 55% decrease of rETR, respectively was observed showing the onset of Se inhibition. At high Se dose to the culture (25 mg g−1 DW) the course of experiments was different; after 24 and 48 h, the level of Se accumulation was considerably higher—508 and 1370 mg g−1 DW, respectively (5–10 times more than in the presence of 2.5 and 8.5 mg Se g−1). Here, the inhibitory affect was clearly visible as decrease of rETRmax after 24 h (Fig. b). After 72 h Se content in the biomass was too high (not shown here) that we consider it as an artefact, probably due to unspecific adsorption of Se since ETR activity was negligible (Fig. 4b).
The results revealed that at low irradiance intensity (250 µmol photons m−2 s−1) the doses of Se above 8.5 mg g−1 DW were growth-inhibiting. The ‘background’ content of Se in the control cultures was between 15 and 17 µg g−1 DW.
Trial 2: the effect of Selenium on microalgae cultures under various irradiance intensities
Preliminary experiments showed that the limit of Se tolerance is related to photosynthetic activity, i.e. depends on irradiance intensity. Thus, in Trial 2, the effective concentration of 16 mg Se g−1 DW was used (~235 µmol L−1) to study changes of photosynthetic activity and the extent of Se incorporation into biomass under various light intensities (250, 500 and 750 µmol photons m−2 s−1). This range of irradiance intensities was assessed from outdoor experiments where we found the average diel irradiance of ~400 μmol photon m−2 s−1 close to the surface (Masojídek et al. 2011b). The control cultures (no Se added) for each irradiance intensities were set-up in parallel. At low irradiance (250 µmol photons m−2 s−1), the biomass density increased from 1.57 to 2.5 g L−1 during a 3-day trial (Fig. 2b). The rise of light intensity to 500 and 750 µmol photons m−2 s−1 increased the growth rate of Chlorella cultures more than 2 and 4 times, respectively to reach 3.5 and 6 g biomass L−1 at the end of the trial. It is important to note that similarly as in Trial 1, a slow-down of growth and photosynthetic activity of the cultures was always accompanied by a release of volatile Se compounds; it indicated that Se was not metabolized.
The courses of growth curves were reflected by RLCs and OJIP kinetics. After 24 h, RLCs measured in the control cultures revealed high rETR values of about 210 at 750 µmol photons m−2 s−1 while this activity was by 10–20% lower at 500 and 250 µmol photons m−2 s−1 (Figs. 3c, d, 4e). In the presence of Se, the growth at the medium irradiance (500 µmol photons m−2 s−1) was stimulated being higher by about 24% after 72 h as compared to the control culture (Fig. 2b). (Interestingly, the course of growth at 500 µmol photons m−2 s−1 in the Se presence was almost identical as in the control at 750 µmol photons m−2 s−1). At the medium irradiance rETR was higher in the Se-treated culture after 48 h as compared to the control; the significant inhibition was seen only after 72 h as it dropped to 33% of the initial value (Figs. 3d, 4e). The addition of Se to the low and high irradiance (250 and 750 µmol photons m−2 s−1) caused a 20–25% inhibition of growth as compared to the control cultures, but we have to consider different final biomass densities (Fig. 2b). Similarly at in the case of RLC, the course of the OJIP curves revealed that the Se-treated cultures at 500 µmol photons m−2 s−1 were least inhibited as compared to those exposed to 750 and 250 µmol photons m−2 s−1. At medium irradiance, the Vj and Vi variables were only slightly increased in the presence of Se after 72 h (Fig. 6c, d) while at low and high irradiance these increased significantly indicating a more reduced state of the PSII reaction center, i.e. a block of electron transport.
Chlorophyll content in biomass of the control cultures was about 2.2–2.3% at the start and the maximum values of were reached in low irradiance culture (3.2) while, logically these maxima were 2.1 and 1.8 in the cultures exposed to medium and high irradiance, respectively (Fig. 7b). In the Se–treated cultures, the total Chl content did not changed substantially.
In low-irradiance cultures, Se incorporation was high on Day 2; but after 72 h, similarly as in Trial 2 at high Se dose, the content of Se in biomass was extremely high (not shown here) that can be consider as an artefact, probably due to unspecific adsorption of Se to deprived cells as ETR activity was negligible (Fig. 4d). The highest Se accumulation in biomass (7100 µg g−1 DW) was found in Chlorella cultures under medium irradiance after 72 h (Fig. 8b) when rETR was still 27% of the maximum activity. As the Se-content of Se in the control cultures was between 15 and 17 µg g−1 DW, it means that well-growing Chlorella can accumulate Se up to thousand-times in their biomass. At high irradiance the Se incorporation into biomass was low that we consider as the consequence of activity inhibition by the Se+ high irradiance synergism.
Trial 3: cultivation of outdoor Chlorella culture with selenium
In Trials 1 and 2, laboratory Chlorella cultures grown under continuous illumination were able to well tolerate certain concentrations of Se (2.5 mg g−1 DW, corresponding to 37 μmol L−1) without substantial inhibition of growth for 3 days (Figs. 2, 3, 4). On the basis of Trial 1 and 2 and some preliminary outdoor studies (not shown here) we estimated the dose of Se for outdoor longer-term trial test presented here. The aim of this experiment was to produce Se-enriched Chlorella biomass in longer run with high amount of Se incorporated into biomass while minimizing growth inhibition and Se losses.
The starting biomass density was about 13 g L−1 as we took in consideration that light path in outdoor thin-layer cascades was only 6 mm and the trial was carried out at the beginning of June when daily irradiance is relatively high and the diel period is long. In this trial the average concentration of Se was about 20 µmol L−1, i.e. total dose of Se was about 0.8 mg g−1 biomass supplied during 7 days. This dose was adjusted significantly lower than the lowest dose (2.5 g Se g−1 DW) in laboratory Trial 1 that still caused inhibition of rETR after 3 days of experiment and volatile Se compounds were released. In Trial 3 we intended to avoid substantial inhibition of growth. Indeed, in the Se-treated culture was only slightly decreased (5–10%) as compared with the control culture (Fig. 9). No substantial changes of RLC were found in the middle and at the end of the trial (Day 4 and 7) as compared to Day 1 (Additional file 1: Figure S1). The variables rETRmax and Ek showed the trends of slightly decreasing activity in the Se-treated culture at midday (Table 1) that probably reflected increased biomass density. Changes of the OJIP-curves (Additional file 1: Figure S2) and the derived Vj and Vi variables also indicated only a negligible decrease of photosynthetic activity of the Se-treated culture as compared to the control (Table 1). Nevertheless, at the end of 1-week trial the biomass density was about 26.7 g L−1 (about 15% lower than in the control). The total yield of biomass harvest was about 50 kg containing 650 mg Se kg−1 DW; about 80% of the added selenite amount was incorporated. We can conclude that we were able to select suitable Se dose that was only mildly inhibiting photosynthetic activity and growth but still the incorporation of Se to biomass was relatively high (compare with Fig. 8). Chl fluorescence was used as fast and suitable technique to monitor doses of Se salts.
Toxic effect of Se salts is dependent on microalgae species as well as culturing conditions. Thus, prior to production of Se-enriched biomass, specific toxicity analysis for the selected species is required as seen in our trials. As an example published data for the microalga Chlorella can be taken for comparison. She can tolerate Se concentrations of up to tens of mg L−1 depending on culturing conditions (Pelah and Ephraim 2005; Gojkovic et al. 2014; Sun et al. 2014). It is important to consider that reported laboratory cultures were mostly grown in flasks in rather diluted suspensions exposed to 50–100 µmol photons m−2 s−1. Not much attention has been paid to the dependence of Se effect at varying irradiance intensities that have been proven as crucial in our trials. Se doses have been usually expressed in mg per liter or molar concentration, but we have to consider biological effect which depends on the ratio between Se concentration and biomass density (g Se per g DW).
Scarce reports can be found describing the physiological effects of Se in detail (added in the form of selenite or selenate) in correlation to biomass productivity and element uptake in microalgae cultures. Here photosynthesis monitoring is essential technique for cultivation control and evaluation of Se tolerance/toxicity in microalgae cultures. When culturing in excessive Se concentrations the early response of microalgae culture is significant decrease of photosynthetic activity monitored as oxygen evolution or Chl fluorescence quenching (e.g. Geoffroy et al. 2007; Gojkovic et al. 2014; Morlon et al. 2005).
In the present experiments with Chlorella cultures, a range of Se concentrations (2.5–85 mg L−1, i.e. 0.03–1 mM) was used as referred for various microalgae in the literature (for a review see Gojkovic et al. 2015) and we exposed Chlorella cultures to higher irradiance intensity, closer to values measured inside the culture outdoors (250–750 µmol photons m−2 s−1; Masojídek et al. 2011b) at higher biomass densities (~1.5 g L−1). The extent of Se effect was dependent on the culture treatment, i.e. Se dose, irradiance intensity and time of exposure. According to our results, Chlorella was able to accumulate Se concentration in her cells up to 1000-fold more than it is normally found during cultivation (Fig. 8). This process was, to a certain extent, stimulated by photosynthetic activity (irradiance intensity) until the synergism of increasing irradiance intensity and of Se dose caused photo inhibition (Figs. 3b, c, 4d–f, 5c, d). It is a typical situation described by Lichtenthaler (1988) as eu-stress, a mild stress activating cell metabolism and increasing physiological activity vs. dis–stress, having a negative, damaging effect. We have demonstrated that low Se concentration of about 2.5–8.5 mg g−1 DW (19–65 µM) partially stimulated photosynthetic activity (rETR) and growth of Chlorella for the first 24 h (Fig. 4b). Further on, Se above the tolerable level showed its toxic effect that was indicated by the significantly decreased growth (Fig. 2). Similar trend was also found by Sun et al. (2014) as the growth of Chlorella was promoted by Se at lower concentrations. The inhibitory effect of Se salts on photosynthetic yield has been related to ultrastructural changes (Geoffroy et al. 2007; Morlon et al. 2005; Vítová et al. 2009; Schiavon et al. 2016). Chloroplasts are probably the first target of Se cytotoxicity affecting the stroma, thylakoids and pyrenoids as electron microscopy showed the over-accumulation of starch and the formation of dense granules containing Se (Morlon et al. 2005).
As the Se concentration was increased (25 mg g−1 DW, i.e. 190 µmol L−1), it led to a significant reduction in photosynthetic activity and subsequently growth rate (Figs. 2a, 3a, b). The decrease of photosynthetic activity was accompanied, for some period, by increased Se incorporation to biomass (0.5–1.5 mg g−1 DW). This is in agreement with the results obtained with different microalgae species like Spirulina, Chlamydomonas or Chlorella sorokiniana (Geoffroy et al. 2007; Gojkovic et al. 2014; Li et al. 2003; Morlon et al. 2005). In our experiments growth inhibition at higher Se doses, which resulted in decreased incorporation of Se, was also accompanied by “sulphurous” smell of volatile compounds released during cultivation. At higher Se doses when the culture activity was significantly inhibited (and Se was not incorporated) was this physiological state always accompanied by “sulphurous” smell of volatile Se compounds released during cultivation as mentioned by Guadayol et al. (2016). Se uptake probably employs the enzymatic metabolism resulting in the substitution of some of the sulphur atoms by Se in both free amino acids and proteins as demonstrated by the presence of Se-analogues of the sulphur amino acids during Se accumulation (Li et al. 2003; Araie and Shiraiwa 2016). The higher Se doses can also result in an enhanced accumulation, probably, due to the sorption to cell walls (Pronina et al. 2002) as these consist of variety of extracellular organic compounds such as polysaccharides and proteins that offers a number of active sites capable of binding metal ions (Mane and Bhosle 2012).
When we exposed Chlorella cultures to medium light intensities of 500 µmol photons m−2 s−1, about a 40% stimulation of growth was observed in a 3-day experiment even in the presence of 16 mg Se g−1 DW (Fig. 2). However, further increase of light intensity to 750 µmol photons m−2 s−1 was photo inhibitory, as it was revealed by lowered Fv/Fm and rETRmax values (compared to the control), indicating that high irradiance amplified the effect of Se presence on the PSII complex (Fig. 4e).
It is important to note that rETR was more sensitive variable to the Se treatment as compared to the maximum photochemical yield Fv/Fm (Fig. 4). Actually, the effective PSII photochemical yield YII (used for rETR calculation) was more sensitive to Se treatment as compared to Fv/Fm (Fig. 4a, b; Geoffroy et al. 2007). In any case, we consider the variable rETR more suitable as compared to as YII as the former takes into account also irradiance intensity EPAR that influence Se incorporation. Based on our Chl fluorescence data—RLCs and OJIP kinetics, changes of Chl fluorescence variables Fv/Fm, rETRmax, Ek, Vj and Vi (Figs. 3, 4, 5, 6) we believe that higher Se doses obstruct photosynthetic electron transport between PSII and PSI due to the over reduction of plastoquinone electron carriers. Thus the balance between excitation and electron transfer rate is changed and results in a more reduced state of the PSII reaction center as also reported by Chen et al. (2016). These conclusions in supported by our results as the increase of Vj and Vi (Fig. 6a and c) indicated accumulation of the reduced plastoquinones that cannot transfer electrons further (Strasser et al. 2004). Some authors hypothesize that the presence of Se probably also affects the Cyt b-6f complex (Geoffroy et al. 2007; Gojkovic et al. 2015). Because of their chemical similarity, Se can substitute sulphur in an iron–sulphur protein that is a part of the complex. This may eventually lead to disruption of the photosynthetic electron transport chain as Cyt b6f plays the role as an electron carrier from PS II to PS I. Eventually, this also indirectly affects the O2 evolution rate as the water-splitting complex is also associated with PS II. These are the early photochemical events affecting photosynthesis, supporting the fact that the PSII complex is very sensitive to abiotic stresses (Jajoo et al. 2016), for example the presence of Se in excess.
A better understanding of the overall effect of Se on microalgae has been needed to develop biotechnological processes for the production of Se-enriched biomass containing valuable organic Se–compounds. The main motivation of this work was to study the interplay between the dose and irradiance in order to find the range of Se tolerance in laboratory and outdoor cultures. Therefore, we wished to find fast and suitable methods and key variables in order to optimize doses of Se salts preventing growth inhibition, or even culture loss in large-scale mass cultivation. Monitoring photosynthetic performance via Chl fluorescence diagnostics can give us the early warning to prevent toxic effect (and also release of unpleasant volatile Se compounds) during cultivation. It can also help to follow metabolic pathway of Se in the cells, but it is out of the scope of this work. From a biotechnological point of view, we are able to achieve efficient incorporation of Se by microalgae cells (Se-enriched of biomass) controlled by photosynthesis monitoring without substantial decrease of growth rate.
electron transport rate
fast fluorescence induction curve
rapid light curve
Araie H, Shiraiwa Y (2016) Selenium in Algae. In: Borowitzka MA, Beardall J, Raven J (eds) The physiology of microalgae developments in applied phycology 6. Springer International Publishing, Switzerland, pp 281–288. doi:10.1007/978-3-319-24945-2_12
Becker EW (2007) Microalgae as a source of protein. Biotechnol Adv 25:207–210
Bennett WN (1988) Assessment of selenium toxicity in algae using turbidostat culture. Water Res 22:939–942
Chen T, Zheng W, Luo Y, Yang F, Bai Y, Tu F (2005) Effects of selenium stress on photosynthetic pigment contents and growth of Chlorella vulgaris. J Plant Physiol Mol Biol 31:369
Chen Z, Song SH, Wen Y, Zou Y, Liu H (2016) Toxicity of Cu (II) to the green Chlorella vulgaris:a perspective of photosynthesis and oxidant stress. Environ Sci Pollut Res 23:17910–17918. doi:10.1007/s11356-016-6997-2
Conde JE, Sanz Alaejos M (1997) Selenium concentrations in natural and environmental waters. Chem Rev 97:1979–2003
Doucha J, Lívanský K, Kotrbáček V, Zachleder V (2009) Production of Chlorella biomass enriched by selenium and its use in animal nutrition: a review. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 83:1001–1008
Eilers PHC, Peeters JCH (1988) A model for the relationship between light intensity and the rate of photosynthesis in phytoplankton. Ecol Model 42:199–215
Fan TWM, Lane AN, Higashi RM (1997) Selenium biotransformations by a euryhaline microalga isolated from a saline evaporation pond. Environ Sci Technol 31:569–576
Fournier E, Adam-Guillermin C, Potin-Gautier M, Pannier F (2010) Selenate bioaccumulation and toxicity in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Influence of ambient sulphate ion concentration. Aquat Toxicol 97:51–57
Geoffroy L, Gilbin R, Simon O, Floriani M, Adam CH, Pradines C, Cournac L, Garnier-Laplace J (2007) Effects of selenate on growth and photosynthesis of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Aquat Toxicol 83:149–158
Gojkovic Ž, Garbayo I, ArizaJ LG, Marova I, Vilchez C (2015) Selenium bioaccumulation and toxicity in cultures of green microalgae. Algal Res 7:106–116
Gojkovic Ž, Vílchez C, Torronteras R, Vigara J, Gomez- Jacinto V, Janzer N, Gomez-Ariza JL, Márová I, Garbayo I (2014) Effect of selenate on viability and selenomethionine accumulation of Chlorella sorokiniana grown in batch culture. Sci World J 2014:13. doi:10.1155/2014/401265
Goltsev VN, Kalaji HM, Paunov M, Bąba W, Horaczek T, Mojski J, Kociel H, Allakhverdiev SI (2016) Variable chlorophyll fluorescence and its use for assessing physiological condition of plant photosynthetic apparatus. Russ J Plant Physiol 63:869–893
Guadayol M, Cortina M, Guadayol JM, Caixach J (2016) Determination of dimethyl selenide and dimethyl sulphide compounds causing off-flavours in bottled mineral waters. Water Res 92:149–155
Hofstraat JW, Peeters JC, Snel JFH, Geel C (1994) Simple determination of photosynthetic efficiency and photoinhibition of Dunaliella tertiolecta by saturating pulse measurements. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 103:187–196
Jajoo Kalaji HM, Oukarroum A, Brestic A, Zivcak M, Samborska IA, Cetner MD, Lukasik I, Goltsev V, Ladle RJ (2016) Chlorophyll a fluorescence as a tool to monitor physiological status of plants under abiotic stress conditions. Acta Physiol Plant 38(4):102. doi:10.1007/s11738-016-2113-y
Kooten O, Snel JF (1990) The use of chlorophyll fluorescence nomenclature in plant stress physiology. Photosynth Res 25:147–150
Kouba A, Velíšek J, Stará A, Masojídek J, Kozák P (2014) Supplementation with sodium selenite and selenium-enriched microalgae biomass show varying effects on blood enzymes activities, antioxidant response, and accumulation in common barbel (Barbus barbus). BioMed Res Int 2014:408270. doi:10.1155/2014/408270
Kromkamp JC, Forster RM (2003) The use of variable fluorescence measurements in aquatic ecosystems: differences between multiple and single turnover measuring protocols and suggested terminology. Eur J Phycol 38:103–112
Larsen EH, Hansen M, Fan T, Vahl M (2001) Speciation of selenoaminoacids, selenonium ions and inorganic selenium by ion exchange HPLC with mass spectrometric detection and its application to yeast and algae. J Anal Atom Spectrom 16:1403–1408
Li ZY, Guo SY, Li L (2003) Bioeffects of selenite on the growth of Spirulina platensis and its biotransformation. Bioresour Technol 89:11–176
Lichtenthaler HK (1988) In vivo chlorophyll fluorescenceas a toolfor stress detection in plants. In: Lichtenthaler HK (ed) Application of chlorophyll fluorescence. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp 129–142
Malapascua J, Jerez C, Sergejevova M, Figueroa FL, Masojidek J (2014) Photosynthesis monitoring to optimize growth of microalgal mass cultures: application of chlorophyll fluorescence techniques. Aquat Biol 22:123–140
Mane PC, Kadam DD, Chaudhari RD (2013) Biochemical responses of some freshwater algal species to selenium: a laboratory study. Central Eur J Exp Biol 2(4):27–33
Mane PC, Bhosle AB (2012) Bioremoval of some metals by living algae Spirogyra sp. and Spirullina sp. from aqueous solution. Int J Environ Res 6:571–576
Masojídek J, Vonshak A, Torzillo G (2011a) Chlorophyll fluorescence applications in microalgal mass cultures. In: Suggett DJ, Prášil O, Borowitzka MA (eds) Chlorophyll a fluorescence in aquatic sciences: methods and applications; book series: developments in applied phycology, vol 4. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 277–292
Masojídek J, Kopecký J, Giannelli L, Torzillo G (2011b) Productivity correlated to photobiochemical performance of Chlorella mass cultures grown outdoors in thin-layer cascades. J Ind Microbiol Biotechnol 38:307–317
Morlon H, Fortin C, Floriani M, Adam C, Garnier-Laplace J, Boudou AB (2005) Toxicity of selenite in the unicellular green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: comparison between effects at the population and sub-cellular level. Aquat Toxicol 73:65–78
Neumann PM, De Souza MP, Pickering IJ, Terry N (2003) Rapid microalgal metabolism of selenate to volatile dimethylselenide. Plant, Cell Environ 26:897–905
Novoselov SV, Rao M, Onoshko NV, Zhi H, Kryukov GV, Xiang Y, Weeks DP, Hatfield DL, Gladyshev VN (2002) Selenoproteins and selenocysteine insertion system in the model plant cell system, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. EMBO J 21:3681–3693
Oh SE, Hassan SHA, Joo JH (2009) Biosorption of heavy metals by lyophilized cells of Pseudomonas stutzeri. World J Microbiol Biotechnol 25:1771–1778
Pardo R, Herguedas M, Barrado E, Vega M (2003) Biosorption of cadmium, copper, lead and zinc by inactive biomass of Pseudomonas putida. Anal Bioanal Chem 376:26–32
Pelah D, Ephraim C (2005) Cellular response of Chlorella zofingiensis to exogenous selenium. Plant Growth Regul 45:225–232
Pronina NA, Kovshova YL, Popova VV, Laptin AB, Alekseeva SG, Baum RF, Mishina IM, Tsoglin LN (2002) The effect of selenite ions on growth and selenium accumulation in Spirulina platensis. Russ J Plant Phys 49:235–241
Ralph PJ, Gademann R (2005) Rapid light curves: a powerful tool to assess photosynthetic activity. Aquat Bot 82:222–237
Schiavon M, Moro I, Pilon-Smits EAH, Citta A, Folda A, Rigobello MP, Vecchia FD (2016) Comparative effects of selenate and selenite on selenium accumulation, morphophysiology, and glutathione synthesis in Ulva australis. Environ Sci Pollut Res 23:15023–15032
Schiavon M, Moro I, Pilon-Smits EAH, Matozzo V, Malagoli M, Vecchia FD (2012) Accumulation of selenium in Ulva sp. and effects on morphology, ultrastructure and antioxidant enzymes and metabolites. Aquat Toxicol 122:221–231
Schreiber U, Schliwa U, Bilger W (1986) Continuous recording of photochemical and non-photochemical chlorophyll fluorescence quenching with a new type of modulation fluorometer. Photosynth Res 10:51–62
Serodio J, Vieira S, Cruz S, Coelho H (2006) Rapid light-response curves of chlorophyll fluorescence in microalgae: relationship to steady-state light curves and non-photochemical quenching in benthic diatom-dominated assemblages. Photosynth Res 90:29–43
Šetlík I, Berková E, Doucha J, Kubín Š, Vendlová J, Zachleder V (1972) The coupling of synthetic and reproduction processes in Scenedesmus quadricauda. Arch Hydrobiol Algol Stud 7:172–213
Strasser RJ, Tsimilli-Michael M, Srivastava A (2004) Analysis of the chlorophyll a fluorescence transient. In: Papageorgiou GC, Govinjee R (eds) Chlorophyll a fluorescence: a signature of photosynthesis. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 321–362
Strasser RJ, Srivastava A (1995) Polyphasic chlorophyll a fluorescence transient in plants and cyanobacteria. Photochem Photobiol 61:33–42
Sun X, Zhong Y, Huang Z, Yang Y (2014) Selenium accumulation in unicellular green alga Chlorella vulgaris and its effects on antioxidant enzymes and content of photosynthetic pigments. PLoS ONE 9(11):e112270. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0112270
Umysová D, Vítová M, Doušková I, Bišová K, Hlavová M, Čížková M, Machát J, Doucha J, Zachleder V (2009) Bioaccumulation and toxicity of selenium compounds in the green alga Scenedesmus quadricauda. BMC Plant Biol 9:58
Vítová M, Bišová K, Hlavová M, Zachleder V, Rucki M, Čížková M (2011) Glutathione peroxidase activity in the selenium-treated alga Scenedesmus quadricauda. Aquat Toxicol 102:87–94
Vriens B, Behra R, Voegelin A, Zupanic A, Winkel LHE (2016) Selenium uptake and methylation by the microalga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Environ Sci Technol 50:711–720
Wellburn AR (1994) The spectral determination of chlorophyll a and b, as well as total carotenoids, using various solvents with spectrophotometers of different resolution. J Plant Physiol 144:307–313
Wheeler AE, Zingaro RA, Irgolic K (1982) The effects of selenate, selenite and sulphate on the growth of six unicellular marine algae. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 57:181–194
White S, Anandraj A, Bux F (2011) PAM fluorometry as a tool to assess microalgal nutrient stress and monitor cellular neutral lipids. Bioresour Technol 102:1675–1682
Zachleder V, Šetlík I (1982) Effect of irradiance on the course of RNA synthesis in the cell cycle of Scenedesmus quadricauda. Biol Plant 24:341–353
Design of the experiments: JM, AB, KR, JRM. Experiments performed by: AB, KR, JRM, JM. Data analyses: AB, JRM, KR, JM. The article written by: JM, AB, JRM, KR. Graphics: AB, KR, JM. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors thank to Mr. Petr Novotný and Ms. Soňa Pekařová for technical assistance. The research was financed by the Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports of the Czech Republic, National Program of Sustainability, grant Algatech Plus LO1416. Ms. Azadeh Babaei from the School of Chemical Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Tehran, Iran was a visiting scientist to the Algatech Centre supported by UNESCO stipend.
The authors declare that the research was supported by grants listed below. No commercial or financial can be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Availability of data and materials
The original data supporting the final conclusions are kept by the authors. Chlorella vulgaris, strain R117 was designated as CCALA 10258 and deposited in the Culture Collection of Autotrophic Organisms, Institute of Botany, Třeboň, Czech Republic.
About this article
Cite this article
Babaei, A., Ranglová, K., Malapascua, J.R. et al. The synergistic effect of Selenium (selenite, –SeO3 2−) dose and irradiance intensity in Chlorella cultures. AMB Expr 7, 56 (2017) doi:10.1186/s13568-017-0348-7
- Chlorophyll fluorescence
- Irradiance intensity
- Selenium incorporation