Skip to main content

Table 4 Combined assay performance for GM ELISA, Aspergillus RT-PCR, and Aspergillus NASBA-ELISA when testing cases of proven/probable IA

From: Development and evaluation of enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay of nucleic acid sequence-based amplification for diagnosis of invasive aspergillosis

parameter

NASBA-ELISA ora RT-PCR

NASBA-ELISA andb RT-PCR

NASBA-ELISA or GM-ELISA

NASBA-ELISA and GM-ELISA

RT-PCR or GM-ELISA

RT-PCR and GM-ELISA

Sensitivity

97.22 (85.4799.93)

55.56 (38.10–72.06)

83.33 (67.19–93.63)

55.56 (38.10–72.06)

77.78 (60.85–89.88)

52.78 (35.49–69.59)

Specificity

68.00 (53.30–80.48)

94.00 (83.45–98.75)

62.00 (47.17–75.35)

100 (92.89100)

66.00 (51.23–78.79)

98.00 (89.35–99.95)

Positive likelihood ratio

3.04 (2.02–4.57)

9.26 (2.98–28.82)

2.19 (1.50–3.22)

Infinity

2.29 (1.50–3.49)

26.39 (3.70188.24)

Negative likelihood ratio

0.04 (0.01–0.28)

0.47 (0.33–0.69)

0.27 (0.13–0.58)

0.44 (0.31–0.64)

0.34 (0.18–0.64)

0.48 (0.340.68)

PPV [% (95 % CI)]

68.63 (54.11–80.89)

86.96 (66.41–97.22)

61.22 (46.24–74.80)

100 (83.16100)

62.22 (46.54–76.23)

95.00 (75.13–99.87)

NPV [% (95 % CI)]

97.14 (85.0899.93)

74.60 (62.06–84.73)

83.78 (67.99–93.81)

75.76 (63.64–85.46)

80.49 (65.13–91.18)

74.24 (61.99–84.22)

Youden index

0.652

0.496

0.453

0.556

0.438

0.508

  1. Combined analysis for both proven IA (n = 9) and probable IA (n = 27)
  2. Best performance values are highlighted in italics
  3. a “or” indicates that at least one of the assays is required to be positive
  4. b “and” indicates that both assays are required to be positive before a patient is considered positive